Tuesday, November 13, 2018

Corporate Budgeting: Paying People to Lie

Michael Jensen's timeless classic is available here.  In it he describes how stock market analysts set earnings expectations for a company's stock.  Since the CEO is paid in stock options which will decline in value if earnings fall short of analysts' expectations, the CEO wants to ensure that each division makes enough money to meet analysts' expectations.  In consultation with division managers, she turns analysts' earnings expectations into performance metrics, with each division manager's bonus tied to meeting her division's share of company earnings. 

With these incentives, each division manager has an incentive to understate (or lie about) how much her division can earn.  As a results, the negotiated division budgets need not reflect what managers actually know.   Important decisions are then made based on based on budgets constructed from lies.

Fortunately, there is an easy fix:

 [by]...changing the way organizations pay people. In particular to stop this highly counterproductive behavior we must stop using budgets or targets in the compensation formulas and promotion systems for employees and managers. This means taking all kinks, discontinuities and non-linearities out of the pay-for-performance profile of each employee and manager. Such purely linear compensation formulas provide no incentives to lie, or to withhold and distort information, or to game the system.


With a linear compensation scheme, there is no incentive to understate how much a division will earn.  And with better information, better decisions are made:

I believe that solving the problems could easily result in large productivity and value increases - sometimes as much as 50 to 100% improvements in productivity.

1 comment:

  1. CLASSIC CYBER NOTCH
    How well are you prepared for a Cyber incident or Breach?, Is your Data safe?
    Strengthen your Cybersecurity stance by contacting CLASSIC CYBER NOTCH @ GMAIL DOT COM for a Perfect, Unique, Classic and Professional Job in Securing your Network against all sort of breaches and from scammers as well.
    For we are Specially equipped with the Best hands to getting your Cyber Hack needs met as your jobs will be handled with utmost professionalism.

    We do All type of cyber Jobs such as:
    ☑ TRACKING of GPS location, cars, Computers, Phones (Apple, windows and Android), e.t.c.
    We also Track
    E-MAIL account,(G-mail, Yahoo mail, AOL, Proton mail, etc.)
    SOCIAL MEDIA account, (Facebook, Twitter, Skype, Whatsapp, e.t.c.)

    ☑ RECOVERY of Passwords for E-mail address, Phones, Computers, Social media Accounts, Documents e.t.c

    ☑ INSTALLATION of Spy ware so as to spy into someone else's computer, phone or E-mail address and also Installation of Spy ware software on your individual O.S to know if your Gadget is being hacked into..
    We also Create and Install VIRUS into any desired computer gadget.

    ☑ CRACKING Websites, any desired gadget it computers or phones, CCTV Survelance camera, Data base (of both Private and Govt organization, such as Schools, Hospitals, Court houses, The FBI, NSA) e.t.c....

    NOTE:
    Other Jobs we do are:
    ☑ We provide Private Investigator service
    ☑ Clearing Criminal records of diverse type
    ☑ Binary Options fraud Recovery
    ☑ Bitcoin Mining
    ☑ Issuing of Blank ATM cards
    ☑ And many more... etc.

    We assure you that your Job will be attended to with care and efficiency as it will be handled by the Best professional hands in Cyber literacy.
    We also have a forum where you can get yourself equipped with Advanced hacking Knowledge..

    CLASSIC CYBER NOTCH gives you the Best service in the Hacking world.

    Be sure to 📱 💻 us @

    Classic cyber notch at gmail dot com

    any time, any day to get the Best Professional hands involved in putting a smile on your face.
    We're Classic Notch

    Signed,
    Collins .A.

    ReplyDelete