Here is an opinion piece I had tried to get into publication. Alas, no takers.
Grand Theft Auto VI arrives tomorrow after a 13-year wait. Its predecessor sold 230 million copies, and the sequel is widely rumored to be the first billion-dollar video game production. Expectations for this installment are even higher. Millions of players will suddenly have an unusually attractive way to spend their time. Some will take vacation days or call in sick. Students will skip class or study less. For a few days, perhaps weeks, GTA VI will compete directly with work and school.
Economists have sometimes treated such behavior as evidence that better video games are pulling young men away from work. But that confuses a temporary leisure shock with permanent withdrawal from productive life. Better games make leisure more valuable and work less attractive. The basic economics is surely right. When leisure becomes better, people consume more of it. GTA VI should provide a spectacular demonstration. Where will that time come from?
Consider football. An estimated 26 million Americans planned to miss work the Monday after the 2026 Super Bowl. Millions expected either to fake illnesses or simply not show up. Yet no one interpreted Super Bowl Monday as evidence that football had caused a collapse in Americans' attachment to the labor force. Fans watched the game, stayed up too late, celebrated too much and went back to work. We treat the Super Bowl as an event, not a new labor-market equilibrium.
A blockbuster video game creates a similar shock to the attractiveness of leisure, with one important difference: Super Bowl parties end after a few hours. Large video games can consume dozens, even hundreds, of hours. GTA VI could compete with work and school not just for one Monday morning but for evenings and weekends over several weeks. That makes the disruption potentially larger, but not necessarily more permanent.
There is reason to doubt that gaming explains young men's long-run retreat from work. Economist Gray Kimbrough found that much of the rise in gaming displaced television, movies and other electronic leisure, while men leaving employment did not show unusually strong preferences for gaming. Screen time substitutes for screen time. Weak labor-market opportunities may explain more than Xboxes do.
The evidence for shorter-run displacement is much clearer. In my research on time use, I found that when newly released video games became more attractive, students played more and devoted less time to educational activities. They cut class and spent less time on homework. But the effects lasted only weeks. Games did not turn students permanently away from education; they temporarily displaced it when an especially fun game was released.
That distinction matters because lost workdays and lost school days are not equivalent. A worker who uses a vacation day to play GTA VI may simply move leisure from December to November. A student who skips Thursday's economics lecture cannot move that lecture to December. Temporary distraction can therefore have lasting consequences when what gets displaced is human-capital investment.
The people affected are also changing. Those disruptions were once concentrated among the demographic group most associated with gaming: young men. In another study, Benjamin Engelstätter and I documented a multidecade shift toward a more mainstream audience. Gaming grew most quickly among groups that historically played less: older adults, the more educated, moderate-income households and racial minorities. More recent industry data put the average American player at 37, with women accounting for nearly half of players. The next irresistible release will compete for the time of a much broader swath of the labor force.
Playing is only part of the story. Esports tournaments such as Dota 2's International and the League of Legends World Championship draw millions of viewers. Their fans face the same temptation as football or basketball fans to rearrange sleep, school and work around important matches. Employers know when the Super Bowl is played and when March Madness begins. Far fewer know when major esports championships are underway.
Gaming is becoming more mainstream, major releases are becoming larger cultural events, and esports is creating an expanding calendar of occasions that compete for time. Employers and educators should expect these disruptions to become more common and should get better at recognizing them. But they should not confuse a temporary surge in leisure with mass withdrawal from productive life. GTA VI will disrupt work and school. What it probably will not do is persuade millions of Americans to abandon either.


